New York made me realize that I’m in a complete and utter transition mode. It also made me realize that I’m having a freakishly good life. At least by the average standards and that kind of lifts the pressure and just makes you want to go a bit nuts. Which I will.
I just to figure out some stuff about myself.
The whole identity topic was kind of an issue for time for me. No wonder, right? For somebody who lived in so many different countries and cities, it’s kind of an obligatory thing to start thinking about this stuff at some point. Living without a citizenship and not having the feeling of belonging to one specific country doesn’t help either. Don’t get me wrong, I’m rather liking it not having a citizenship. It’s always a good conversation starter and it kind of makes me feel like I really do live on the Internet. One step closer to a global citizenship? Maybe, it’s rather pointless to call it something because this status is so seldom that it’s not really helping to belong to something.
Belonging is actually what it’s all about.
I never had the urge to belong to somewhere or somewhat, but it seems like I’m developing it right now. Don’t know why. Maybe it’s an age thing. But thinking about it and especially being in New York mixed a whole lot of things up and in my case it made me think a lot about Judaism and what it actually means in my life. I would argue – and that’s a spoiler! – that it’s very important. Not because I’m religious. I’m not at all, but this cultural background kind of dominates who I’m anyway. Not as much in Germany, but it sure is very obvious for me in the US. Probably because people are talking about Judaism or religion more openly. But especially with Judaism it always gets very awkward in Germany. People are always trying to be much more pc as soon as they hear that I’m a Jew. History is still being processed and I’m very sure that Judaism never ever will be as openly debated in Germany as it can be in the US.
And it’s kind of neat for me being here and being able to take in my family, the cultural background and discuss this topic in a different way here. People are actually differentiate here between cultural Judaism and religious Judaism. That’s very interesting, I would definitely fit into the first category. But you could make things even more complicated. There are a lot of different Jews here. In my case, it’s the Sowjet Union/Russia background that makes things even more interesting.
I’ll give you an example: Up until now all my girlfriends where German. That was never really an issue. Not for me, not for my parents. At least not like on a substantial level. But being in immigrant with a lot of different, not utterly unproblematic backgrounds, it always led to different awkward situations. Introducing your girlfriend to you parents and especially introducing your parents to your girlfriends parents was always like a cultural clash. Again, it never was an issue and there wasn’t any real tension there, but it was something you one needed to work through.
And I’m witnessing the same issues with my cousins here. In our family, we are the generations that stands between two worlds. We have this Jewish/Russian background in our genes, but we’re being confronted with a very different world on a daily basis. For me especially it’s even more confusing, because in 99% of the time I’m not being confronted with my background in my daily life. But not being confronted with it doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s easier to process.
To come back to this whole girlfriend example: I never really came into the phase where the relationship went into this serious area of really talking about marriage and having kids or something. It came up, but it always felt far away. But at some point I always knew that it would be something that would make me a huge headache. Why? Well, have you been to a Jewish wedding? If not, it helps, if you saw “My Big Fat Greek Wedding”. We’re obviously not Greek, but the whole family stuff isn’t really made up and it’s as troublesome with Jews as it’s with Greeks. Not that I’m somebody who would do something utterly out of obligation to my family, but it would be awesomely complicated to tell my huge, scattered family that there won’t be any Jewish ceremony or wedding style, because I’m not that into that and I’m marrying a German girl who is certainly not into that.
I’m not really sure that this post is going somewhere specific, so I will end it here. It might actually be just something that I wrote for myself and not something that necessarily needs any publishing, but I kinda want it to be out there and if somebody have any thoughts on this self finding, cultural mixed up situation … fire away.


I can really understand what you are talking about:
Last year my girlfriend (like me, she has an south-italian background) went to sicily for vacation to meet her family there. In this situation I got a really clear view, that this experience can only be that cool, if you are a couple with the same background.
Besides speech, there is a huge range of little things in life, which are typical italian (especially in the south) and never will be understood by someone from germany or another county. Which is not very astonishing, but neither always on the peoples minds.
I think it´s a great thing, if you can share those little things in your partnership.
— emzo · Mar 13, 06:23 PM · #
Yeah, that sounds about right.
But in a way, it makes me kind of sad that it’s that way. Mainly because I would never look for a partner specifically from one community. It would weird me out. Also, I’m a big romantic. I believe that serendipity should work it’s magic, when it comes to something like this and it’s very likely that I’m not going to end up with somebody from my original community, because I mainly have very different people in my life right now.
Does this mean, that I’m probably going to make compromises? Probably, yes. It’s the price for seeing so many parts of the world, I guess. It’s okay too. Everybody needs to compromise in complex systems like a relationship.
— Igor Schwarzmann · Mar 17, 07:42 PM · #
Since I´m kind of romantic too, I did not search for a girl of italian origin or something. It was just by fluke, meeting each other and having a common way of life. The chance to get together was (maybe) just a bit bigger because of our same background.
If your partner is from the same ethnic group, you´ll have to make compromises, too! I think seeing the world and different cities has always the same price: Less time to get a close contact to other people.
— emzo · Mar 17, 08:03 PM · #
Yeah, I wasn’t implying that you’ve actively looked for somebody from your ethnic group. Didn’t think of you as “one of those”. ,)
As for my travelling / way of life … well, I guess you’re right, yeah. But it feels good right now, so I’ll stick with my gut feeling and just walk the road as it comes along.
— Igor Schwarzmann · Mar 17, 08:07 PM · #
I can (or try to) imagine your emotional dilemma, it is weird but isn’t exactly that what you named a “global citizenship” our attitude?
In my opinion we (I say we, but I of course I can just speak for myself) are global. I don’t care about nationalities, religions or any other pigeonholings. I care about opinions and attitudes.
And if people think the same way, I feel “home”. In my opinion not a place makes you feel “home”, but the people around you. When I was in NY I felt home, when I was in Regensburg I felt home, it took a while until I felt home here in Hamburg but right now I don’t want to be anywhere else right now (although Berlin felt quiet good last week).
— Markus · Apr 22, 05:58 PM · #
I don’t know, places do have a certain appeal to me. Not sure why, because the idea of a “global citizenship” sure does sounds like something without a certain location, but I can’t not say of myself that I would appreciate that.
It might be, because of my roots or better yet the fact that I didn’t have this one place of belonging. It might also be that I actually want to live in Israel. There is a very romantic idea of this country in my head. I strongly suspect that’s because I was basically a kid while being there and I all my memories seem very peaceful and warm. Despite the fact that we witnessed a war with all the gas masks wearing and explosions in the neighbourhood.
Anyway, what I wanted to say is: I kinda like the idea of a place of belonging, but I fully understand and agree with your argument. It’s not the place that defines us, but the ideas and thoughts and the people that surround us. Yes, I can’t disagree with that.
We are very fortunate to have the ability this way. It’s basically only possible because of the Internet. It didn’t only gave us access to the information that helped us form ourselves, but also took this idea of separation between people. On the Internet we are all the same and there no boundaries (well, okay … you know …).
— Igor · Apr 22, 07:10 PM · #
Ok, maybe that is the difference between us. Wherever I was, I had somewhere in my mind that I still have my roots in Düsseldorf. This is the place where all my family is and still most of my friends I grew up with. In fact most of my family (since my grandparents settled in Düsseldorf after the 2nd WW) still is in Düsseldorf. There are just 2 of us who moved away (my cousin and me). And also 3 of my 4 best friends from school still are in Düsseldorf.
So, I move around the world, meet a lot of new friends, who are still in contact with me but my roots are my roots. These friends are not better or more close to me but different.
And I can’t imagine not having it, my roots. It’s a crazy imagination.
But I have the urge to move, to travel and to live in different places. And like you said, the internet doesn’t make it easier. I meet a lot of people, I get in contact with creatives from SF or NY and would like to say “Do you have a job?” or “Can I visit you?” but there are several other things which are playing a big role in my life, which are influencing me. So, we’ll see where I will live in 5 years.
— Markus · Apr 22, 10:17 PM · #